Soothe2 vs Gullfoss: Two Resonant Suppressors on the Same Harsh Synth Stab

I put Soothe2 and Gullfoss on the same harsh synth stab last week, soloed, level matched, and listened until the difference stopped being subtle. They are not the same tool wearing different skins. One reacts to what the signal is doing. The other reacts to what the room is doing to the signal. That distinction decides which one you reach for, and on a brutal saw stab it shows up fast.

The stab in question: a three-note detuned supersaw hit through a bright filter, printed into the arrangement as audio. Harsh around the upper mids, with a resonant peak that moved every time the notes changed. Exactly the kind of material that makes you want to reach for a resonant suppressor before you reach for a static EQ notch.

What each plugin is actually doing

Soothe2 is a dynamic resonance suppressor. It examines the incoming signal and attenuates frequencies based on what it hears in real time, working like a very dense multi-band compressor with an EQ-style display you can draw on. Sage Audio’s mastering writeup makes the point well: where a multiband compressor would attenuate unrelated frequencies, and most de-essers grab a whole top-end band, Soothe2 works only on the relevant parts of the signal. That surgical selectivity is the whole reason people put it on a synth bus.

Gullfoss does something different. It is a self-adjusting EQ that analyzes the spectral balance and makes broad corrective moves toward what it considers neutral. Think of it as an intelligent tonal balancer rather than a resonance hunter. You give it a target and a bias, it decides which frequencies need pulling or pushing, and it moves fast enough to follow a changing source. The processing is wider and more global than Soothe2’s per-peak approach.

Both attenuate. Both are tonal correction. But one is a scalpel aimed at specific resonances and the other is a hand on the overall EQ tilt. On a harsh stab, the scalpel usually wins the first round and the hand wins the second.

The A/B on the stab

I ran Soothe2 first, using a soft setting with limited attenuation, 2x oversampling in ultra mode, and sharpness up to make the cuts more precise. That combination is close to how Sage Audio describes using it before saturation, which is the correct placement. If you are going to distort a sound, suppress the resonances before the distortion, not after, or you amplify the aggressive frequencies you were trying to tame.

The result on the stab: the resonant peak at the front of each note got rounded off without the note losing its bite. The character stayed. The harshness moved back. Two passes of dialing got me there.

Gullfoss on the same stab did something I would describe as rebalancing rather than suppressing. It pulled the upper-mid emphasis down and nudged the low end up to compensate, and the stab sounded more even in the mix instantly. But the specific resonant peak, the one that made my ears flinch on the highest note, was still there. Gullfoss averaged it out. Soothe2 removed it. Different jobs.

Where Gullfoss gets annoying

I do not fully trust Gullfoss on material with strong transients and fast pitch movement. The stab changes register across three notes, and the plugin’s response lags just enough that one note gets treated harder than the others. You can tune the speed, but there is a trade-off. Too fast and it chases the signal and sounds unstable. Too slow and it misses the peak entirely.

It also makes decisions for you. On a mix bus, that is fine. On a single synth, I want control over which frequency gets pulled, not an algorithm’s opinion about balance. Gullfoss is doing tonal correction on top of a sound I already tuned deliberately. Sometimes that is helpful. Sometimes it is a plugin arguing with my arrangement.

Soothe2 gives me the display and lets me decide. More work, more predictable result. The EQ-style interface means I see what is being attenuated and can limit it to the upper spectrum, which is exactly what I did on this stab.

Where Soothe2 bites back

Soothe2 is not free of problems. It is heavy. Multiple instances on a busy session will cost you CPU, and the ultra mode plus oversampling makes it worse. You enable those modes when you need the precision, not by default. On a 90-track indie session I would not put it on every channel. I would put it on two or three and print the result.

The other thing: it is easy to over-suppress. If you leave it in with attenuation high, you will hollow out the source and wonder why the stab lost its energy. The fixes are soft mode, limited attenuation, and a sharpness setting that keeps the cuts narrow. Over-processing is the default mistake and the plugin does not stop you.

The verdict

For a harsh synthetic stab, Soothe2 is the tool. It targets the resonance, leaves the rest of the sound alone, and lets you decide how much to cut. Gullfoss is for broader tonal shaping, a final balance pass on a bus or a full mix, or a fast tone fix when you do not want to think about frequencies at all.

The workflow I landed on: Soothe2 first to suppress the specific resonant peak, then a light Gullfoss pass on the stem bus to even out the tonal balance across the whole part. Not either/or. Sequential. Soothe2 does the surgical work, Gullfoss does the balancing work, and neither one argues with the arrangement anymore.

Both plugins cost real money and neither replaces knowing what the problem frequency sounds like before you open the GUI. If you cannot hear the resonance without the plugin bypassed, the plugin is not the answer. It is confirmation of something you already heard, which is all a resonant suppressor should ever be.